Skip to main content

2009 BMW 328i: Oil 3 Quarts Over and a Broken Oil Filter Housing

Our tech went over a 2009 BMW 328i and found the oil 3 quarts over full, a broken oil filter housing and low differential fluid. Here is the full list.

A silver 2009 BMW 328i sedan in the shop with the hood up and tools resting on the engine Real Supercanic Job Photo
The 328i in our shop with the hood up, on the day of the inspection.

Quick answer. This 2009 BMW 328i came in for a diagnostic. Our tech found the oil 3 quarts over full, a broken oil filter housing, a PCV valve housing that needs to be replaced, a valve cover that needs to be set back in place and a differential low on fluid. The brakes looked new. The list was bigger than the number the owner had approved, so the tech stopped and asked for a new yes.

Key Points

  • The engine oil was 3 quarts over the full mark. It needs to be drained and filled to the right level.
  • The oil filter housing was broken, and the PCV valve housing needs to be replaced.
  • The differential was low on fluid and needs a service.
  • The brakes front and rear still looked new. One rotor needs to be turned.
  • The work was bigger than what was approved, so the tech stopped and the owner gets a new quote first.

Read our guides a lot? Star Supercanic as a source in Google and our new posts show up more often in your Top Stories.

What Our Tech Found

The owner asked for a diagnostic. Our tech went over the whole car and wrote down every problem, worst first.

The worst one is the oil. It was 3 quarts over full. The fix in the notes is plain. Drain it, change the oil, and fill it to the right level.

Next is the oil filter housing. The tech wrote that it is broken. On this engine the oil filter sits in that housing, so a broken one is not something to ignore.

The PCV valve housing needs to be replaced too. And the valve cover needs to be set back in place.

Then the back of the car. The differential was low on fluid and needs a service.

The top of the engine bay on a 2009 BMW 328i with two round black housings open
Under the hood during the inspection. The oil filter housing was one of the parts our tech flagged.

The Good News Was the Brakes

Not everything was bad. The tech wrote that the brakes front and rear still look brand new.

One thing to watch. The passenger side rotor needs to be turned. The tech's advice is to have all of the rotors turned at the next brake service, not today.

A front brake rotor and caliper on a 2009 BMW 328i with the wheel off
A front rotor on this car with the wheel off. The brakes still looked new.

Why the Tech Stopped

The list was bigger than the number the owner had said yes to. So our tech stopped. That is our rule. The owner gets a new quote and gives a new yes before any more work is done.

The record does not say yet what the owner chose. So we will not tell you it got fixed. We will only tell you what the tech found.

That rule lives inside Shop Desk, the software our San Jacinto shop built and that any mechanic can use free. When a job grows, it stops the job and asks first.

2009 BMW 328i, November 20

Came in for: a diagnostic.

Tech found: oil 3 quarts over, broken oil filter housing, PCV valve housing to replace, valve cover to set in place, differential low on fluid.

Brakes: look new front and rear. Passenger side rotor needs turning.

Where it stands: stopped for a new quote and a new yes. No final bill on record.

Only what is on the job record. Nothing here is a guess.

Why Too Much Oil Is a Problem

People think more oil is safer. It is not. When the level is too high, the spinning crank can slap the oil and whip it into foam, and Cars.com explains that oil pumps do not pump foam well. Pressure drops and parts of the engine can go short of oil. The same article says the fix is to drain oil out until the level is right.

This is general. The record on this car says the oil was 3 quarts over and needs a drain and a change. It does not say the engine was hurt.

Oil Filter Housings on This BMW

On BMW six cylinders like the 328i, the oil filter housing is a known spot for leaks. A BMW parts seller, BimmerWorld, says the housing gasket shrinks and gets hard with age. Its kit page also warns that the oil can drip onto the serpentine belt and make it fail.

This car's record says the housing itself is broken, not just the gasket. Either way, oil near that belt is a reason to fix it soon.

BMW Recalls Worth a Check

One recall touches the same part of the engine. NHTSA recall 17V683000 covers certain 2007 to 2011 328i cars. The heater for the PCV valve may short circuit and melt parts of the valve, which raises the risk of a fire. The NHTSA page for the 2009 328i lists it.

A second one, NHTSA recall 19V472000, covers certain 2009 328i cars. The battery cable connection at the fuse box may wear and cut power, which can stall the car. Both recalls apply to certain vehicles only. This car's record does not show whether either one was done. You can check yours by VIN on the NHTSA recall page.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it bad to have too much oil in my BMW?

Yes, if it is well over the full mark. Too much oil can foam up and lower oil pressure. On this 328i it was 3 quarts over, and our tech called for a drain and an oil change.

What does a broken oil filter housing do?

The oil filter sits in that housing. When it is broken or its seal goes bad, oil can leak out, and on this engine it can drip near the belt.

Do I need new brakes if the rotors need turning?

Not always. On this car the brakes looked new. Our tech said to turn the rotors at the next brake service.

Will you start a bigger repair without asking me?

No. If the work grows past what you approved, we stop. You get a new quote and give a new yes first.

Does a recall mean my car has the problem?

No. A recall covers certain cars. Check your VIN with NHTSA, and a BMW dealer does recall work free.

What We Read

Supercanic tip: Check your dipstick after every oil change, on level ground with the engine off. If it reads way over full, call us at (951) 904-2477 before you drive far.

Share This Guide Text It Facebook

Want Your Car Checked Top to Bottom?

We find it, write it down and show you before we fix anything.